The 7 Psychology Biases in Interviews (And How to Use Them in Your Favour)
- Martin Hill
- Nov 20
- 6 min read
According to Forbes, 48% of hiring manager admit that unconscious bias influences which candidates they choose to hire, often without even realising it. (Forbes, 2023)
Hiring decisions are rarely 100% logical. They’re human, and humans are influenced by biases. The mental shortcuts our brains take when making choices under pressure, with limited information, or when assessing people quickly.
I’ve been recruiting for nearly two decades, working with hiring managers across Asia and Europe, If there’s one truth I’ve seen consistently, it’s this. The best candidate doesn’t always get the job. It’s the candidate who manages perception the best.
In fact, job seekers unknowingly sabotage themselves by triggering common cognitive biases that influence interviewers.
The good news? Once you understand these biases, you can use them to your advantage, ethically and intentionally to improve your visibility, confidence, and impact throughout the hiring process.
Here are the seven psychology biases that shape your job search, and how to turn each one into a competitive edge.
1. Confirmation Bias: First Impressions Decide the Direction of the Interview
Within the first 60 to120 seconds of meeting you, interviewers form an opinion.
After that, their brain looks for evidence that confirms it. This is why a weak intro can derail an otherwise brilliant candidate, every answer is filtered through that initial impression.
How this hurts your job search:
If your opening feels unclear, hesitant, or unfocused, interviewers unconsciously “decide” you’re average… and everything after that becomes harder work.
How to use this bias in your favour:
Start the interview strong with a tight, outcome driven introduction, covering three things:
Who you are (role + scope)
What you’ve done (biggest achievements)
What you’re known for (your “anchor strength”)
Example:
“I’m a Senior HR Business Partner specialising in organisational development and transformation. In my last role, I redesigned our talent development and capability framework across five markets, which strengthened leadership bench readiness and reduced early-tenure turnover by 18%. I’m known for building trust quickly and delivering change that sticks.”
You give them a lens to view the rest of the conversation and a strong story for them to confirm.
2. Recency Bias: People Remember the Last Thing You Say
Interviewers often see a string of candidates back to back, they forget the details, but they remember the ending.
How this hurts your job search:
If you fizzle out at the end “No more questions from me” you leave no closing impression.
How to use it in your favour:
End the interview with a 30 second power summary that highlights your core strength, your biggest achievement, why you’re a strong fit for the role, and what genuinely excites you about it.
Example:
“To summarise: I bring 8 years of scaling customer service teams across APAC, a proven record of reducing churn, and deep experience managing high volume environments. This role aligns perfectly with my strengths in building systems and developing people, and I’m confident I can create immediate value in the first 90 days.”
You finish strong and memorable.
3. The Halo Effect: One Great Strength Shapes Their Entire Perception
Interviewers latch onto one standout trait and it colours everything else. It’s unfair, but it works both ways.
How this hurts your job search:
If you don’t actively present a “halo,” interviewers default to whatever impression stands out… which might not be what you want.
How to use it in your favour:
Introduce one signature achievement early, something with big numbers, a major transformation, a painful problem you solved, a complex challenge you led, or something broken that you turned around.
Example: “A major achievement for me was overhauling our entire fulfilment workflow. Orders were constantly delayed, customer complaints were high, and the team was firefighting daily. I redesigned the process end to end, introduced new metrics, and retrained the team. Delivery times dropped by 32% and we eliminated a backlog that had been growing for months.”
Then refer back to it naturally throughout the interview. This creates a psychological “halo” that amplifies everything else.
4. Availability Bias: You’re Being Compared to the Candidate They Saw Before You
Interviewers don’t compare you to all candidates. Only the ones they remember most clearly… often the one they interviewed just before you.
How this hurts your job search:
If the last candidate was strong and you blend in, you become forgettable.
How to use it to your favour:
After the interview, send a short thank you message that restates your 2 to 3 strongest points, reminds them of your biggest achievement, and includes a one page ‘Value Summary’ or ‘Portfolio of Wins’ if it’s appropriate.
Example Subject: Thank You for your time
Hi [Name],
Thanks again for today, I really appreciated hearing about [specific challenge, priority, or goal they mentioned]. It gave me a clear picture of what success in this role looks like.
The work I’ve done in [relevant area], especially [your strongest achievement], aligns closely with what your looking for and I’d be excited to bring that experience to your team
I’ve attached a one page Value Summary with the key wins most relevant to the role.
Looking forward to the next steps.
Kind regards
[Your Name]
Your goal is to stay top of mind not lost in the interview pile.
5. Anchoring Bias: The First Number You Give Sets Your Value
When salary comes up, most candidates anchor themselves too low. And once that number is said…it’s almost impossible to raise it later.
How this hurts your job search:
You anchor yourself to your current salary (big mistake).
You anchor too early and limit negotiation.
You give a range so wide it sounds unsure.
How to use this bias in your favour:
Anchor on market value, not your current paycheck.
Say something like:
“Based on the scope discussed and current market rates for similar roles, I’m exploring opportunities in the range of $120,000 - $130,000”
You set the starting point, shape how your value is perceived, and avoid getting lowballed.
6. Competency Illusion Bias: You Think They Understand Your Value. They Don’t
This one is brutal but honest: Highly competent people often assume interviewers “get” their achievements and they don’t.
Interviewers are often tired, distracted, multitasking, unfamiliar with your industry, and juggling ten other priorities.
How this hurts your job search:
You under explain your impact, focus on tasks instead of outcomes, and expect the interviewer to connect the dots for you.
How to use this bias in your favour:
Spell out your value clearly:
Context → Action → Result
Example:
“We were losing 20% of customers within the first 60 days. I redesigned the onboarding process, created a follow up framework, and aligned product and support teams. Within six months, churn dropped to 7% and customer lifetime value increased 14%”
You remove ambiguity and make your impact undeniable.
7. Attribution Bias: How You Explain Problems Determines If They Blame You or Trust You
When you describe challenges, interviewers look for “fault.” If you aren’t careful, they assume you were the issue.
How this hurts your job search:
When candidates talk about difficult bosses, toxic cultures, poor performing teams, or failed projects, they often sound defensive or emotional.
How to use this bias in your favour:
Use blameless accountability:
State the situation factually
Define your role
Show what you learned
Show how you improved things
Example:
“My previous manager had a very hands off approach, which created misalignment across the team. I set up weekly check ins, clarified priorities, and introduced shared KPIs. It created transparency and improved our delivery times.”
You sound mature, self aware, and solution focused.
Why Understanding Psychological Biases in Interviews Gives You a Competitive Edge
In a competitive market, the difference between two shortlisted candidates is rarely about capability. It’s about clarity, confidence, perception, memorability, communication, and managing bias.
These biases shape how interviewers interpret you, remember you, and advocate for you internally.
When you learn to use them intentionally, you shift from being “a good candidate” to being the obvious hire.
Final Thoughts: Master the Psychology, Win the Interview
Psychological biases in interviews aren’t barriers. They’re tools, if you know how to work with them. You may not control who else applies or what mood your interviewer is in. But you can control how you show up, what stories you tell, and how memorable you make your case.
For more ways to sharpen your job search strategy, check out How to increase your interviews in 30 days, The Most Common CV Mistakes to Avoid, and 7 Hidden Interview Questions
Comments